Bible Commentary

Isaiah 1:11

The Pulpit Commentary on Isaiah 1:11

The Pulpit Commentary · Joseph S. Exell and contributors · Public domain

To what purpose is the multitude of your sacrifices unto me? Cui bono? What good end do they serve? "Thinkest thou that I will eat the flesh of bulls, and drink the blood of goats? "( :13).

God "delights not in burnt offerings." From the time of Samuel he had declared, "Behold, to obey is better then sacrifice, and to hearken than the fat of rams" (). David had said of him, "Sacrifice and meat offering thou wouldest not; burnt offerings and sacrifice for sin hast thou not required" (, ); and again, "I will not reprove thee because of thy sacrifices, or for thy burnt offerings, because they were not always before me.

I will take no bullock out of thy house, nor he-goat out of thy folds; for all the beasts of the forest are mine, and so are the cattle upon a thousand hills" (). Not, of course, that either David or Isaiah desired to abolish sacrifice, or had any commission so to do; but they were, both of them, anxious to impress on men that sacrifice, by itself, was nothing—that self-dedication, self-renunciation, true devotion of the heart, with its necessary concomitant obedience, must accompany sacrifice, for God to be pleased therewith.

The sacrifices of a people such as is described in verses 21-23 could not but be an offence to him. Saith the Lord. The phrase employed is unusual, and almost confined to Isaiah, occurring elsewhere only in .

Isaiah uses it again in verse 18, and also in ; ; and . It is explained to be emphatic, implying that this is what God says, and will say, concerning the matter in hand, once and forever (Kay).

I am full of the burnt offerings of rams; rather, I am overfull, satiated, wearied with them. Barns formed a part of the required sacrifice on all great occasions, as at the Passover (), at the Feast of Weeks (), at the Feast of Tabernacles (, , , , , , , ), at the Feast of Trumpets (), and on the great Day of Atonement ().

They were commanded as the sole sacrifice for a trespass offering (Le , ). Under David were offered on one occasion "a thousand rams" (); and the occasions where seven rams formed the legitimate sacrifice were many.

Unaccompanied by a proper frame of mind, each such offering was an offence to God, displeased him, wearied him. The fat of fed beasts. The fat was always regarded, both by the Hebrews and the Greeks, as especially suitable for sacrifice.

It was burnt upon the altar in every case, even where the greater part of the victim was consumed as food (see Le , ; , , etc.; note particularly the expression in Le , "All the fat is the Lord's").

"Fed beasts" are those which were kept separate in stalls or sheds for some time before the sacrifice, and given food in which there was nothing" unclean." The Paschal lambs were required to be thus separated and fed for four days (, ).

I delight not in the blood. The blood, "which is the life" (Le ), was to be sprinkled on the altar in every sacrifice of a victim. This sprinkling was of the very essence of the sacrifice (Le ; , , ; , 17, 25, 30, etc.

). Bullocks … lambs … he-goats. These, together with rams, constituted all the sacrificial beasts of the Hebrews.

Recommended reading

More for Isaiah 1:11

Continue with other commentaries and DiscipleDeck content connected to this verse, chapter, or topic.

Other commentaries

The Pulpit Commentary on Isaiah 1:1-31Isaiah 1:1-31 · The Pulpit CommentaryPART I.—EARLIER PROPHECIES OF ISAIAH (CH. 1-35.) SECTION I.—THE GREAT ARRAIGNMENT (Isaiah 1:1-31.). EXPOSITIONMatthew Henry on Isaiah 1:10-15Isaiah 1:10-15 · Matthew Henry Concise CommentaryJudea was desolate, and their cities burned. This awakened them to bring sacrifices and offerings, as if they would bribe God to remove the punishment, and give them leave to go on in their sin. Many who will readily pa…The Vanity of Mere Ritual Obedience. (b. c. 738.)Isaiah 1:10-15 · Matthew Henry's Commentary on the Whole BibleTHE VANITY OF MERE RITUAL OBEDIENCE. (B. C. 738.) Here, I. God calls to them (but calls in vain) to hear his word, Isaiah 1:10. 1. The title he gives them is very strange; You rulers of Sodom, and people of Gomorrah. Th…The Pulpit Commentary on Isaiah 1:10-20Isaiah 1:10-20 · The Pulpit CommentaryThe prophetic strain. Isaiah had gone only a very little way in his testimony when he broke into the true prophetic strain. The prophets were God's witnesses against the mere shows and semblances of piety, and for the r…The Pulpit Commentary on Isaiah 1:10-15Isaiah 1:10-15 · The Pulpit CommentaryTHE PEOPLE'S PLEA NO EXCUSE, BUT AN AGGRAVATION OF THEIR GUILT. The prophet supposes the people, by the mouth of their rulers, to meet the charge of rebellion with an appeal to the fact that they maintain all the outwar…The Pulpit Commentary on Isaiah 1:10-17Isaiah 1:10-17 · The Pulpit CommentaryThe people's plea considered. The leading men of Jerusalem are supposed to reply to the charge of Jehovah, pointing to the elaborate manner in which his worship is kept up. And Jehovah rejects their plea with scorn. I.…
commentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Isaiah 1:1-31PART I.—EARLIER PROPHECIES OF ISAIAH (CH. 1-35.) SECTION I.—THE GREAT ARRAIGNMENT (Isaiah 1:1-31.). EXPOSITIONJoseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryMatthew Henry on Isaiah 1:10-15Judea was desolate, and their cities burned. This awakened them to bring sacrifices and offerings, as if they would bribe God to remove the punishment, and give them leave to go on in their sin. Many who will readily pa…Matthew HenrycommentaryThe Vanity of Mere Ritual Obedience. (b. c. 738.)THE VANITY OF MERE RITUAL OBEDIENCE. (B. C. 738.) Here, I. God calls to them (but calls in vain) to hear his word, Isaiah 1:10. 1. The title he gives them is very strange; You rulers of Sodom, and people of Gomorrah. Th…Matthew HenrycommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Isaiah 1:10-17The people's plea considered. The leading men of Jerusalem are supposed to reply to the charge of Jehovah, pointing to the elaborate manner in which his worship is kept up. And Jehovah rejects their plea with scorn. I.…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Isaiah 1:10-15THE PEOPLE'S PLEA NO EXCUSE, BUT AN AGGRAVATION OF THEIR GUILT. The prophet supposes the people, by the mouth of their rulers, to meet the charge of rebellion with an appeal to the fact that they maintain all the outwar…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Isaiah 1:10-20The prophetic strain. Isaiah had gone only a very little way in his testimony when he broke into the true prophetic strain. The prophets were God's witnesses against the mere shows and semblances of piety, and for the r…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Isaiah 1:11-13Mere ceremonial an offense to God. What a painful sight it would be to see some of our houses with the fronts off!—to look into the abodes of vice; to witness the impurity and profanity, and wretchedness and wild licens…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Isaiah 1:11-14The outward form of religion, without inward piety, an offence to God. It is strange how deeply ingrained the idea is in man, that formal acts of worship, outward acknowledgment, ritual, ceremonial, pageantry, constitut…Joseph S. Exell and contributors