Bible Commentary

Hosea 5:4

The Pulpit Commentary on Hosea 5:4

The Pulpit Commentary · Joseph S. Exell and contributors · Public domain

In this verse their evil doings are traced to an evil spirit of whoredoms that is, of idolatries, which impels them blindly and resistlessly to evil, while at the same time it expels the knowledge of God.

The first clause is differently rendered. The textual rendering of the Authorized Version, viz. they will not frame (literally, give, direct) their doings to turn unto their God, denotes their total and absolute refusal to repent or to bring forth fruits meet for repentance.

The actions are an index of the state of the heart, but neither the thoughts of Israel at this time, nor their deeds which indicated these thoughts, were in the direction of repentance. In heart and life they were impenitent.

This rendering is supported by most of the Hebrew commentators. Rashi says, "They forsake not their evil way;" Aben Ezra," They perform not works so as to turn." Kimchi also gives an alternative sense: "Or the sense of the words is thus: They cling so closely to their evil works, that even should they for once conceive in their heart the idea of turning, they immediately repent them of it."

The marginal rendering also yields a good sense; it is, Their doings will not suffer (allow) [them] to turn unto their God. The pronominal suffix for "them" is wanting, yet it may be dispensed with, as the appending of it to "doings" and "God" makes the sense sufficiently explicit.

It is favored by Ewald, Keil, the Targum, and Kimchi, who explains: "Their evil works do not allow them to return to their God, as if he said, To such extent have they multiplied transgression that there is no way left them to return, until they receive their punishment."

Such and so great was the power of their evil habits that they could not break them off or break away from them by repentance; or so intimately connected is a change of heart with a change of life that, in the absence of the latter, the former is impossible.

According to either rendering, the reason assigned is contained in the next clause: For the spirit of whoredoms is in the midst of them, and they have not known the Lord. So overmastered were they, as though by some fiendish spirit that held them in check and exercised despotic power over them, that they rushed headlong down the steep incline, like the Gadarene herd of swine, which, when the unclean spirits entered into them, ran violently down a steep place into the sea.

Neither was there any counteracting force to turn them back or reverse their course. Such a force might have been found in the knowledge of God, of his covenant mercy, of his power, love, grace, and goodrich.

But this was wanting, and the absence of this knowledge at once increased their impenitence and aggravated their guilt. It was Israel's privilege and Israel's duty to know the Lord; for he had revealed himself to them as to no other nation; he had given them his Law, he had made them depositaries of his truth and the conservators of his living oracles; their ignorance, therefore, was altogether inexcusable, while it evinced greatest ingratitude to Jehovah, who had taken them into covenant with himself, and declared himself to be their God.

Recommended reading

More for Hosea 5:4

Continue with other commentaries and DiscipleDeck content connected to this verse, chapter, or topic.

Other commentaries

Matthew Henry on Hosea 5:1-7Hosea 5:1-7 · Matthew Henry Concise CommentaryThe piercing eye of God saw secret liking and disposition to sin, the love the house of Israel had to their sins, and the dominion their sins had over them. Pride makes men obstinate in other sins. And as Judah was trea…Charge against Israel and Judah; Judgments Threatened. (b. c. 758.)Hosea 5:1-7 · Matthew Henry's Commentary on the Whole BibleCHARGE AGAINST ISRAEL AND JUDAH; JUDGMENTS THREATENED. (B. C. 758.) Here, I. All orders and degrees of men are cited to appear and answer to such things as shall be laid to their charge (Hosea 5:1): Hear you this, O pri…The Pulpit Commentary on Hosea 5:1-5Hosea 5:1-5 · The Pulpit CommentaryGod here arraigns the sins of princes, priests, and people. Their degeneracy had been very great and their sins very grievous. Though there is no formal catalogue given of those sins, yet they are incidentally exhibited…The Pulpit Commentary on Hosea 5:1-10Hosea 5:1-10 · The Pulpit CommentaryNational sin and punishment. The general strain of this chapter is similar to that of the preceding. "The judgment" (Hosea 5:1) which has already been pronounced there is still continued. In Hosea 4:1-19; however, Judah…The Pulpit Commentary on Hosea 5:1-7Hosea 5:1-7 · The Pulpit CommentaryGod and man. All classes are addressed by the prophet—priests, king, nobles, the whole house of Israel. The prophecy makes an advance. In the previous chapter judgment is threatened; in this it is announced as imminent.…The Pulpit Commentary on Hosea 5:1-15Hosea 5:1-15 · The Pulpit CommentaryEXPOSITION
commentaryMatthew Henry on Hosea 5:1-7The piercing eye of God saw secret liking and disposition to sin, the love the house of Israel had to their sins, and the dominion their sins had over them. Pride makes men obstinate in other sins. And as Judah was trea…Matthew HenrycommentaryCharge against Israel and Judah; Judgments Threatened. (b. c. 758.)CHARGE AGAINST ISRAEL AND JUDAH; JUDGMENTS THREATENED. (B. C. 758.) Here, I. All orders and degrees of men are cited to appear and answer to such things as shall be laid to their charge (Hosea 5:1): Hear you this, O pri…Matthew HenrycommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Hosea 5:1-5God here arraigns the sins of princes, priests, and people. Their degeneracy had been very great and their sins very grievous. Though there is no formal catalogue given of those sins, yet they are incidentally exhibited…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Hosea 5:1-15EXPOSITIONJoseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Hosea 5:1-10National sin and punishment. The general strain of this chapter is similar to that of the preceding. "The judgment" (Hosea 5:1) which has already been pronounced there is still continued. In Hosea 4:1-19; however, Judah…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Hosea 5:1-7God and man. All classes are addressed by the prophet—priests, king, nobles, the whole house of Israel. The prophecy makes an advance. In the previous chapter judgment is threatened; in this it is announced as imminent.…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Hosea 5:4Necessary preliminaries to a godly life. "They will not frame their doings to turn unto their God," etc. Preachers do not always deal wisely with their hearers. They call upon men to repent; they often describe repentan…Joseph S. Exell and contributors