Bible Commentary

John 5:17-47

The Pulpit Commentary on John 5:17-47

The Pulpit Commentary · Joseph S. Exell and contributors · Public domain

(3) The reply of Jesus to the hostile Jews. The discourse of the Lord Jesus, in reply to the persecuting spirit and deadly purpose of the Jewish authorities, is now given at length. There is a fulness and order and progress observable throughout of immense importance as establishing the sacred origin of the words. The simplicity of the style, quite Hebraic in its freedom from conjunctive forms, discriminates it from the Philonic presentation of certain analogous but different ideas. If, as Godet has remarked, we venture on the hazardous speculation that the prologue to the Gospel merely places before us the Philonic conception of θεοσ and λογοσ, making God to be the inconceivable, unapproachable, impersonal Essence, coming into activity in the λογο who is self-dependent, but who exhausts all the vitality and activity of the supreme θεος, we may, with Reuss, find hero what is contrary to both the prologue and to the views of the Divine Being, which repudiate the correlative subordination of the Son of God. But the prologue is based on the identity of nature between θεοσ and λογοσ, and the subordinate and yet eternal relation of the latter to the former. There is an infinite fulness of being and activity in the Father, who yet is and loves and energizes in all things through the λογοσ, the ΄ονογενησ. It appears to us that precisely the same truth is taught here, but it is taught in terms derived from the consciousness of the Logos incarnate, and with reference to a part only of the operations of the Logos, viz. in the providential, redeeming, and quickening work of the Son. This narrative shows how actual revelations of the Logos were made through the human consciousness of him who was lifted up into the being of the Son of God, and who became the Interpreter of the Son to men. The prologue is built upon the discourse—is an inspired and transcendental generalization of the truths here and elsewhere announced. The discourse is the basis of the prologue in the thought of the evangelist. The originality of the discourse is conspicuous. Its theme shows it to be closely allied with the discussions which shortly after this created such fierce animosities in the synagogues of Galilee, whither his Jerusalem enemies pursued him. We shall find that there Jesus declared that "the Son of man was Lord of the sabbath," and was competent in that capacity to assert what was contained and involved in the sabbath. On another occasion he vindicated for his disciples the right to food on the sabbath (),

(a) The claim of special relation with the Father.

Recommended reading

More for John 5:17-47

Continue with other commentaries and DiscipleDeck content connected to this verse, chapter, or topic.

Other commentaries

The Pulpit Commentary on John 5:1-47John 5:1-47 · The Pulpit CommentaryEXPOSITION Here commences the second division of the Gospel (John 5:1) II. THE CONFLICT WITH THE CHOSEN PEOPLE IN JERUSALEM, GALILEE, AND JERUSALEM, TO THE DEATH SENTENCE RECORDED BY THE SANHEDRIN.The Pulpit Commentary on John 5:1-47John 5:1-47 · The Pulpit Commentary1. Christ proved, by signs and wonders and testimonies, to be Source of life.Matthew Henry on John 5:17-23John 5:17-23 · Matthew Henry Concise CommentaryThe Divine power of the miracle proved Jesus to be the Son of God, and he declared that he worked with, and like unto his Father, as he saw good. These ancient enemies of Christ understood him, and became more violent,…Christ's Discourse with the Jews; All Judgment Committed to Christ; The Christian CharterJohn 5:17-30 · Matthew Henry's Commentary on the Whole BibleCHRIST'S DISCOURSE WITH THE JEWS; ALL JUDGMENT COMMITTED TO CHRIST; THE CHRISTIAN CHARTER. We have here Christ's discourse upon occasion of his being accused as a sabbath-breaker, and it seems to be his vindication of h…The Pulpit Commentary on John 5:17John 5:17 · The Pulpit CommentaryThe incessancy of Divine ministry. Healing is work. The sabbath is for rest. Thus the Jews, in their rigid formality, objected against Jesus that, in restoring the infirm and sick man to health and vigour, he had transg…The Pulpit Commentary on John 5:17John 5:17 · The Pulpit CommentaryBut Jesus answered them "that God never ceases to create, nor takes a holiday from his works;" and the author of the Epistle to the Hebrews
commentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 5:1-471. Christ proved, by signs and wonders and testimonies, to be Source of life.Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 5:1-47EXPOSITION Here commences the second division of the Gospel (John 5:1) II. THE CONFLICT WITH THE CHOSEN PEOPLE IN JERUSALEM, GALILEE, AND JERUSALEM, TO THE DEATH SENTENCE RECORDED BY THE SANHEDRIN.Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryMatthew Henry on John 5:17-23The Divine power of the miracle proved Jesus to be the Son of God, and he declared that he worked with, and like unto his Father, as he saw good. These ancient enemies of Christ understood him, and became more violent,…Matthew HenrycommentaryChrist's Discourse with the Jews; All Judgment Committed to Christ; The Christian CharterCHRIST'S DISCOURSE WITH THE JEWS; ALL JUDGMENT COMMITTED TO CHRIST; THE CHRISTIAN CHARTER. We have here Christ's discourse upon occasion of his being accused as a sabbath-breaker, and it seems to be his vindication of h…Matthew HenrycommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 5:17-23Our Lord's vindication of his conduct. It is summarized in a single significant sentence: "My Father worketh hitherto, and I work." I. THE TRUE MEANING OF OUR LORD'S DECLARATION. 1. His Father's life is characterized by…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 5:17The incessancy of Divine ministry. Healing is work. The sabbath is for rest. Thus the Jews, in their rigid formality, objected against Jesus that, in restoring the infirm and sick man to health and vigour, he had transg…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 5:17But Jesus answered them "that God never ceases to create, nor takes a holiday from his works;" and the author of the Epistle to the HebrewsJoseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 5:18Offence with Christ. It might have been expected that a Saviour so compassionate and so beneficent as, even from an ordinary human point of view, Jesus undoubtedly was, would have met with a warm and grateful reception.…Joseph S. Exell and contributors