The Pulpit Commentary on John 9:14

The Pulpit Commentary · Joseph S. Exell and contributors · Public domain

Now it was sabbath on the day £ that Jesus made the clay and opened his eyes. The phrase is peculiar, and implies that the day may have been a festival sabbath. The introduction here shows that the difficulty of the neighbors and other friends had already been raised, and something more than a desire on their part for religious guidance actuated their appeal to the Pharisees.

Why should the healed man be taken to the Pharisees, or the synagogue-court at all, unless some question of casuistry had been raised? The movement was one unquestionably adverse to Jesus. It could have had no other motive.

Nor can any doubt arise that Jesus had violated the rabbinical rules of the sabbath, though his act had been in perfect harmony with the spirit and even letter of the Mosaic Law. The making of clay with the spittle and the sand was an infringement of the rule ('Shabbath,' 24:3).

It was curiously laid down in one of the vexatious interpretations (preserved in Jerusalem Gemara on 'Shabbath,' 14) that while "wine could by way of remedy be applied to the eyelid, on the ground that this might be treated as washing, it was sinful to apply it to the inside of the eye" (Edersheim).

And it was positively forbidden (in the same Gemara) to apply saliva to the eyelid, because this would be the application of a remedy. All medicinal appliances, unless in cases of danger to life or limb, were likewise forbidden.

Consequently, the Lord had broken with the traditional glosses on the Law in more ways than one (see Winer, 'Bibl. Realw.,' 2:346; Lightfoot, ' Ad Joan. 9.; 'Wetstein on Matthew 12:9; Wunsche, in loc.

More for John 9:14

Continue with other commentaries and DiscipleDeck content connected to this verse, chapter, or topic.

Other commentaries

The Pulpit Commentary on John 9:1-41John 9:1-41 · The Pulpit CommentaryEXPOSITION These chapters (9. and 10.) bring the conflict with the Jews to a climax before the commencement of the Peraean ministry. They are doubtless closely connected with what has preceded; but the note of time (Joh…The Pulpit Commentary on John 9:1-41John 9:1-41 · The Pulpit CommentaryThe passage of a soul from darkness into light. This graphic and dramatic narrative begins with the healing of a bodily privation by the exercise el Christ's miraculous power. But its chief interest lies in the spiritua…The Pulpit Commentary on John 9:8-34John 9:8-34 · The Pulpit Commentary(9) The proof of the reality of the miracle, the antagonism of the Pharisees, and the persecution of the heated mad.Matthew Henry on John 9:13-17John 9:13-17 · Matthew Henry Concise CommentaryChrist not only worked miracles on the sabbath, but in such a manner as would give offence to the Jews, for he would not seem to yield to the scribes and Pharisees. Their zeal for mere rites consumed the substantial mat…The Cavilling of the Pharisees; The Cavilling of the Pharisees RefutedJohn 9:13-34 · Matthew Henry's Commentary on the Whole BibleTHE CAVILLING OF THE PHARISEES; THE CAVILLING OF THE PHARISEES REFUTED. One would have expected that such a miracle as Christ wrought upon the blind man would have settled his reputation, and silenced and shamed all opp…The Pulpit Commentary on John 9:13-34John 9:13-34 · The Pulpit CommentaryThe investigation of the miracle. This was prompted by the unfriendly questioners first referred to. I. THE INQUIRY OF THE PHARISEES. 1. They first examined the beggar as to the facts of his cure. These it was as imposs…

commentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 9:1-41The passage of a soul from darkness into light. This graphic and dramatic narrative begins with the healing of a bodily privation by the exercise el Christ's miraculous power. But its chief interest lies in the spiritua…Joseph S. Exell and contributors commentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 9:1-41EXPOSITION These chapters (9. and 10.) bring the conflict with the Jews to a climax before the commencement of the Peraean ministry. They are doubtless closely connected with what has preceded; but the note of time (Joh…Joseph S. Exell and contributors commentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 9:8-34(9) The proof of the reality of the miracle, the antagonism of the Pharisees, and the persecution of the heated mad.Joseph S. Exell and contributors commentaryMatthew Henry on John 9:13-17Christ not only worked miracles on the sabbath, but in such a manner as would give offence to the Jews, for he would not seem to yield to the scribes and Pharisees. Their zeal for mere rites consumed the substantial mat…Matthew Henry commentaryThe Cavilling of the Pharisees; The Cavilling of the Pharisees RefutedTHE CAVILLING OF THE PHARISEES; THE CAVILLING OF THE PHARISEES REFUTED. One would have expected that such a miracle as Christ wrought upon the blind man would have settled his reputation, and silenced and shamed all opp…Matthew Henry commentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 9:13-34The investigation of the miracle. This was prompted by the unfriendly questioners first referred to. I. THE INQUIRY OF THE PHARISEES. 1. They first examined the beggar as to the facts of his cure. These it was as imposs…Joseph S. Exell and contributors