Bible Commentary

John 18:4

The Pulpit Commentary on John 18:4

The Pulpit Commentary · Joseph S. Exell and contributors · Public domain

Jesus then—the οὖν implies that our Lord discerned the approach of the hostile band—knowing all the things that were coming upon him—in full consciousness of his position, and in voluntary sacrifice of himself to the will of God and the purpose of his mission—went forth;£ i.e. from the garden enclosure—see —(say Meyer and Godet); from the recesses of the garden or the garden-house (say others); partly in consequence of the language of the kinsman of Maichus," Did I not see thee in the garden?" But this is perfectly compatible with the obvious fact that the eight disciples and the favored three should have shrunk behind our Lord when he calmly emerged from the entrance to the garden, and that their position would be thus sufficiently indicated. It is remarkable that John, who has been accused of personal malice to Judas (i.e. by those who, like Renan, admit, to a certain extent, the Johan-nine authorship), does not refer to the traitor's kiss. This well-attested and traditionally sustained incident is not excluded by the narrative before us—indeed, the second reference to Judas seems to imply something special in his conduct, which is needed to account for it. We can hardly suppose that it could have taken place before the Lord Jesus had uttered his solemn word, but it may easily have occurred as the first answer to his summons. And saith unto them, Whom seek ye?

They answered him, Jesus the Nazarene. Jesus saith unto them, I am he. Then, in all probability, the miscreant, the son of perdition, said," Hail, Master!" and kissed him; and there followed before and after his act the sublime replies given, "Companion, wherefore art thou come?" and "Judas, betrayest thou the Son of man with a kiss?" John, however, overwhelmed with the majesty and spontaneous self-devotion of the Lord, calls attention to the language he addressed to the "baud" which surrounded him. In some royal emphasis of tone he said, "I am (he)," and the same kind of effect followed as on various occasions had proved how powerless, without his permission, the machinations of his foes really were. In the temple courts, and on the precipice of Nazareth, the murderous Jews and Galilaeans were foiled by the moral grandeur of his bearing; and when he said, I am he, they went backward, and fell to the ground ( χαμαί for χαμάζε). Whether this was a supernatural event, or allied to the sublime force of moral greatness flashing in his eye or echoing in the tone of his voice, we cannot say, but associating it with other events in his history, the supernatural in his case becomes perfectly natural. It was so that he whose "I am he" had hushed the waves and cast out the devil, and before whose glance and word John and Paul fell to the earth, as if struck with lightning, did perhaps allow his very captors (prepared by Judas for some display of his might) to feel how powerless they were against him. It is remarkable that our narrative should place between the "I am he" and its effect, the tautologous remark if there be nothing to explain it, Now Judas also, who was Betraying him, was standing with them. This implies that Judas had taken some step equivalent to that described in the synoptic narrative. There is some momentary consolation in the thought that the traitor fell to the ground with his gang, and for an instant saw the transcendent crime he had committed in betraying the innocent blood with the kiss of treachery and shame. Thoma sees in the approximation of Judas the approach of the prophetic Beast to the true King, and endeavors out of the letters of his name to read the number 666! It is true that represents Satan as having entered into Judas. He stood there, he fell there, with the powers of darkness. What a moment: The devil may have tempted Christ to blast his emissaries with the breath of his nostrils; but, true to his sublime mission, he is occupied only with the safety and future work of those who knew that he had come out from God.

Again then ( οὖν, regarding all the conditions, the cup, the cross, the blood-baptism, the supreme will, all are at stake) he asked them, Whom seek ye? Then, restored from their fright and spasm of conscience, produced by the presence of One whom no fetters, not even those of death itself, could bind, and reassured now by the same voice (cf. ; ), they reply, Jesus the Nazarene. He thus compels them to limit their design, and to single himself out for the malice and devilish plot of their masters. I told you that I am he: if therefore ye seek me, suffer these to depart. There is much in this that lies beneath the surface.

Recommended reading

More for John 18:4

Continue with other commentaries and DiscipleDeck content connected to this verse, chapter, or topic.

Other commentaries

Matthew Henry on John 18:1-12John 18:1-12 · Matthew Henry Concise CommentarySin began in the garden of Eden, there the curse was pronounced, there the Redeemer was promised; and in a garden that promised Seed entered into conflict with the old serpent. Christ was buried also in a garden. Let us…Christ in the Garden; The Treachery of Judas; The Ear of Malachus Cut Off; Christ Yields Himself a PrisonerJohn 18:1-12 · Matthew Henry's Commentary on the Whole BibleCHRIST IN THE GARDEN; THE TREACHERY OF JUDAS; THE EAR OF MALACHUS CUT OFF; CHRIST YIELDS HIMSELF A PRISONER. The hour was now come that the captain of our salvation, who was to be made perfect by sufferings, should enga…The Pulpit Commentary on John 18:1-11John 18:1-11 · The Pulpit Commentary(1) The betrayal, the majesty of his bearing, accompanied by hints of the bitter cup.The Pulpit Commentary on John 18:1-40John 18:1-40 · The Pulpit CommentaryEXPOSITION B. THE HOUR HAS COME.The Pulpit Commentary on John 18:1-11John 18:1-11 · The Pulpit CommentaryThe apprehension of Jesus. The crisis has come at last. I. THE SCENE OF THE ARREST. "He went forth with his disciples over the brook Kedron, where was a garden, into which he entered, and his disciples." 1. The garden w…The Pulpit Commentary on John 18:4-8John 18:4-8 · The Pulpit CommentaryThe moral courage of Jesus. We see this if we consider— I. WHAT HE MIGHT HAVE DONE UNDER THE CIRCUMSTANCES There is no virtue in not doing thus if we cannot do otherwise. But what could Jesus do now? 1. He might have no…
commentaryMatthew Henry on John 18:1-12Sin began in the garden of Eden, there the curse was pronounced, there the Redeemer was promised; and in a garden that promised Seed entered into conflict with the old serpent. Christ was buried also in a garden. Let us…Matthew HenrycommentaryChrist in the Garden; The Treachery of Judas; The Ear of Malachus Cut Off; Christ Yields Himself a PrisonerCHRIST IN THE GARDEN; THE TREACHERY OF JUDAS; THE EAR OF MALACHUS CUT OFF; CHRIST YIELDS HIMSELF A PRISONER. The hour was now come that the captain of our salvation, who was to be made perfect by sufferings, should enga…Matthew HenrycommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 18:1-11The apprehension of Jesus. The crisis has come at last. I. THE SCENE OF THE ARREST. "He went forth with his disciples over the brook Kedron, where was a garden, into which he entered, and his disciples." 1. The garden w…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 18:1-40EXPOSITION B. THE HOUR HAS COME.Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 18:1-11(1) The betrayal, the majesty of his bearing, accompanied by hints of the bitter cup.Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on John 18:4-8The moral courage of Jesus. We see this if we consider— I. WHAT HE MIGHT HAVE DONE UNDER THE CIRCUMSTANCES There is no virtue in not doing thus if we cannot do otherwise. But what could Jesus do now? 1. He might have no…Joseph S. Exell and contributors