Bible Commentary

Genesis 44:3-5

The Pulpit Commentary on Genesis 44:3-5

The Pulpit Commentary · Joseph S. Exell and contributors · Public domain

As soon as the morning was light (literally, the morning became bright), the men (literally, and the men) were sent away, they and their asses. That Joseph did not make himself known to his brothers at the repast was not due to unnatural callousness which caused his heart to remain cold and steeled (Kalisch), or to a fear lest he should thereby destroy the character of his mission which made him the medium of retribution for his brothers (Kalisch), but to the fact that in his judgment either his brothers had not been sufficiently tested, or the time did not appear convenient for the disclosure of his secret. And when they were gone out of the city (literally, they went forth out of the city), and not yet far off (literally, they had not gone far), Joseph (literally, and Joseph) said unto his steward (or man over his house), Up, follow after the men; and when thou dost overtake them, say unto them (literally, and overtake them, and say to them), Wherefore have ye rewarded evil for good? The interpolation at this point of the words, "Why did you steal my silver goblet?" (LXX; Vulgate, Syriac) is superfluous. Is not this it in which my lord drinketh, and whereby indeed he divineth?—literally, and divining he divineth, or maketh trial, in it, the verb נָחַשׁ (from which is derived nachash, a serpent: vide ) originally signifying to hiss or whisper, and hence to mutter incantations, to practice ophiomancy, and generally to divine. The special form of divination here referred to (κυλικομαντεία, or divining out of cups) was practiced by the ancient Egyptians. "Small pieces of gold or silver, together with precious stones, marked with strange figures and signs, were thrown into the vessel; after which certain incantations were pronounced, and the evil demon was invoked; the latter was then supposed to give the answer either by intelligible words, or by pointing to some of the characters on the precious stones, or in some other more mysterious manner. Sometimes the goblet was filled with pure water, upon which the sun was allowed to play; and the figures which were thus formed, or which a lively imagination fancied it saw, were interpreted as the desired omen" (Kalisch). Traces of this ancient practice of soothsaying have been detected by some writers in the magnificent vase of turquoise belonging to Jam-shoed, the Solomon of Persia. Like Merlin's cup, described by Spenser ('Faery Queens,' 3.2, 19)—

"It vertue had to show in perfect sight

Whatever thing was in the world contained

Betwixt the lowest earth and heven's hight,

So that it to the looker appertaynd."

A similar account is given by Homer of the cup of Nestor; and Alexander the Great is reported to have possessed a mystic goblet of a like kind. It is said that in the storming of Seringapatam the unfortunate Tippeo Saib retired to gaze on his divining cup, and that after standing awhile absorbed in it he returned to the fight and fell (vide Kitto's 'Cyclopedia,' art. Divination). Ye have done evil in so doing.

Recommended reading

More for Genesis 44:3-5

Continue with other commentaries and DiscipleDeck content connected to this verse, chapter, or topic.

Other commentaries

Matthew Henry on Genesis 44:1-17Genesis 44:1-17 · Matthew Henry Concise CommentaryJoseph tried how his brethren felt towards Benjamin. Had they envied and hated the other son of Rachel as they had hated him, and if they had the same want of feeling towards their father Jacob as heretofore, they would…Joseph's Policy. (b. c. 1707.)Genesis 44:1-17 · Matthew Henry's Commentary on the Whole BibleJOSEPH'S POLICY. (B. C. 1707.) Joseph heaps further kindnesses upon his brethren, fills their sacks, returns their money, and sends them away full of gladness; but he also exercises them with further trials. Our God thu…The Pulpit Commentary on Genesis 44:1-34Genesis 44:1-34 · The Pulpit CommentaryEXPOSITION Genesis 44:1, Genesis 44:2 And he (i.e. Joseph) commanded the steward of his house,—literally, him that was over his hoarse (Genesis 43:15)—saying, Fill the men's sacks with food, as much as they can carry, a…The Pulpit Commentary on Genesis 44:1-34Genesis 44:1-34 · The Pulpit CommentaryJoseph's artifice to detain Benjamin, or the story of the silver goblet. I. JOSEPH'S STRATAGEM (Genesis 44:1-13). 1. The formation of the plot (Genesis 44:1-5). 2. The execution of the plot (Genesis 44:6-12). 3. The res…The Pulpit Commentary on Genesis 44:1-34Genesis 44:1-34 · The Pulpit CommentaryCharacter built on faith. This chapter continues the same thread of Joseph's policy, and the same lessons are in it. I. PRACTICAL WISDOM THE FRUIT OF PIETY. The true man is the strong man. With a deep knowledge of the h…
commentaryMatthew Henry on Genesis 44:1-17Joseph tried how his brethren felt towards Benjamin. Had they envied and hated the other son of Rachel as they had hated him, and if they had the same want of feeling towards their father Jacob as heretofore, they would…Matthew HenrycommentaryJoseph's Policy. (b. c. 1707.)JOSEPH'S POLICY. (B. C. 1707.) Joseph heaps further kindnesses upon his brethren, fills their sacks, returns their money, and sends them away full of gladness; but he also exercises them with further trials. Our God thu…Matthew HenrycommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Genesis 44:1-34Joseph's artifice to detain Benjamin, or the story of the silver goblet. I. JOSEPH'S STRATAGEM (Genesis 44:1-13). 1. The formation of the plot (Genesis 44:1-5). 2. The execution of the plot (Genesis 44:6-12). 3. The res…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Genesis 44:1-34Character built on faith. This chapter continues the same thread of Joseph's policy, and the same lessons are in it. I. PRACTICAL WISDOM THE FRUIT OF PIETY. The true man is the strong man. With a deep knowledge of the h…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Genesis 44:1-34EXPOSITION Genesis 44:1, Genesis 44:2 And he (i.e. Joseph) commanded the steward of his house,—literally, him that was over his hoarse (Genesis 43:15)—saying, Fill the men's sacks with food, as much as they can carry, a…Joseph S. Exell and contributorscommentaryThe Pulpit Commentary on Genesis 44:5Probation. Divination by cups was practiced by the ancient Egyptians. But no reason to suppose that Joseph actually used this art. It would have been inconsistent with his habitual faithfulness to God, and with the ascr…Joseph S. Exell and contributors